Analyst RoundupExpert OpinionSector Analysis

These stocks could be added to the S&P 500 when benchmark reshuffles this month

CNBCDecember 05, 2025 at 11:25 PMFull Content
View Original →

📊 Workflow Status

✓ CompletedCompleted in 17s
clean_markdown_article
✓ completed
analyze_article
✓ completed
extract_entities
✓ completed
analyze_sentiment
⊘ skipped
Workflow #3645 • scraped_article_processing
Started: 23:25:13 • Completed: 23:25:30
View Details →

Gist

Three stocks—Comfort Systems, Pure Storage, and Ciena—are top candidates for inclusion in the S&P 500 during the upcoming quarterly rebalance, driven by their size and performance in the S&P MidCap 400.

LLM Summary

Stephens analyst Melissa Roberts identified Comfort Systems, Pure Storage, and Ciena as the most likely additions to the S&P 500 in the December 19 rebalance, based on their size and status in the S&P MidCap 400. The S&P Dow Jones Indices committee makes final decisions based on market cap, liquidity, and sector balance, with potential changes limited by high market cap thresholds and a low historical turnover in Q4. Passive funds must adjust holdings when index changes occur, affecting $16 trillion in indexed assets.

Full Article Content

The S & P 500 could see one more big reshuffle before the year ends, with fourth-quarter changes to the benchmark stock index expected on Friday, Dec. 19. In a Wednesday note to clients, Stephens analyst Melissa Roberts pointed to three potential candidates that could get added to the benchmark in the next rebalance. "The most likely eligible adds could be 400 migrators — [ Comfort Systems ] (Industrials), [ Pure Storage ] (IT), and [ Ciena ] (IT) are the three-largest 400 members," she wrote, referring to the S & P Midcap 400 index consisting of companies smaller than those in the S & P 500. Other candidates for potential inclusion due to their size include Carvana , CRH , Vertiv Holdings , Alnylam Pharmaceuticals and Ares Management , she added. However, Roberts noted that there may be few, if any discretionary changes given that the fourth quarter had the lowest historical rebalance turnover, and that a strong M & A pipeline exists for changes. "We believe any changes will focus on index clean-up and migrating oversized and undersized existing members," she wrote. "New member market capitalization guidelines will likely move higher in early Jan. due to market strength, which may limit add opportunities for companies near current cut-offs." An S & P Dow Jones Indices committee inside S & P Global makes the final decision on whether to include a stock in the benchmark index, looking at a company's size, financial strength, the number of public shares available to be traded and how many shares change hands in an average day. The committee also looks at what business the company is in out of a desire to not skew the index too heavily toward one sector or another. Technology accounts for 34.6% of the index today, and communication services, which houses Alphabet and Meta Platforms , another 10.7%. Currently, companies must have at least a $23 billion market capitalization to even be eligible to join the S & P 500 when changes are made, according to Charles Schwab. Index changes are made either during regular quarterly adjustments or as a result of a corporate action, such as a merger or acquisition. Today, S & P Global says the largest stock in the S & P 500 has a market cap of $4.3 trillion while the smallest is worth just $5.5 billion. Goldman Sachs last year estimated that passive, stock index funds own an average of 26% of every stock in the S & P 500. When a stock is added or removed from the index, passive funds are forced to buy or sell shares of that company to keep its representation in the index intact. S & P Dow Jones Indices estimated in 2024 that $16 trillion in total assets under management was indexed or benchmarked to the S & P 500, with passively managed indexed assets comprising $9 trillion.