LLM Job #16676 - score_story_relevance
Conversation
You are a financial news analyst. Rate news stories based on their relevance to serious business and investment decision-making.
Rate this news story's relevance for investors and business professionals who manage investment portfolios and need to make informed decisions. This is ONE news story covered by MULTIPLE news sources. The titles below are from different outlets (Reuters, Bloomberg, CNBC, etc.) all reporting on the SAME business event. Rate the overall story's relevance. Article Titles: 1. Early Addition: Rich people keep on living here 2. Rich New Yorkers Threaten to Leave. Then They Find Out How Hard That Is. 3. ‘There is no Mamdani effect’: Manhattan luxury home sales surge after mayoral election, undercutting predictions of doom and escape to Florida 4. Hochul edges toward tax hikes after Mamdani win Scoring Guidelines: - 9-10: Critical business news (earnings reports, Fed decisions, major M&A, sector-wide impact, regulatory changes) - 7-8: Important analysis (market trends, analyst insights, significant company developments, economic indicators) - 5-6: Relevant news (notable company announcements, industry developments, financial performance) - 3-4: Minor business news (routine updates, small moves, tangential business stories) - 1-2: Fluff/entertainment (celebrity CEO drama, viral marketing, cultural controversies, consumer complaints) High-value examples: - "Wall Street Sentiment on AI Companies Shifts as Earnings Disappoint" (9-10) - "Federal Reserve Minutes Reveal Concerns About Inflation Persistence" (9-10) - "Apple Supplier Cuts Production by 20% Amid Weak iPhone Demand" (8-9) - "Banking Sector Faces Regulatory Scrutiny After Failed Stress Tests" (8-9) Low-value examples: - "Starbucks Cup Design Sparks Outrage on Social Media" (1-2) - "CEO's Dog Makes Appearance at Company Event" (1-2) - "Company Changes Office Snack Selection" (1-2)
{
"explanation": "The news story centers on shifting residential and real estate trends in Manhattan following the mayoral election, particularly the unexpected surge in luxury home sales despite predictions of a mass exodus by wealthy residents to Florida or other states. This phenomenon is linked to political outcomes (Mamdani's win), potential tax policy shifts under Governor Hochul, and broader implications for New York City’s real estate market and economic vitality.\n\nWhile not a direct earnings report or Fed decision, this story reflects a significant market trend with real investment implications: the resilience of high-end urban real estate in a time of political uncertainty. The 'Mamdani effect' (or lack thereof) is being cited as a key factor in investor confidence, suggesting that political change did not trigger capital flight — a critical signal for portfolio managers evaluating exposure to urban real estate, especially in major financial centers.\n\nThe surge in luxury home sales in Manhattan indicates sustained demand for premium real estate assets, which can influence real estate investment strategies, capital allocation, and hedging against economic or political volatility. Additionally, the potential for tax hikes under Hochul adds a layer of regulatory risk that investors must consider when assessing long-term returns on property and urban assets.\n\nThis is not routine or minor news — it reflects behavioral shifts in high-net-worth individuals, market sentiment, and macroeconomic trends affecting asset allocation. It provides actionable intelligence for investors in real estate, hedge funds, and institutional portfolios focused on urban centers and macro risk factors.\n\nTherefore, this story is best rated as 8–9: Important analysis with significant implications for investment decisions, market trends, and risk assessment in a key economic region.",
"score": 8
}Debug Information
▶ Structured Output Schema (JSON Schema)
{
"json_schema": {
"description": "Business relevance score for a news story",
"name": "story_relevance",
"schema": {
"additionalProperties": false,
"properties": {
"explanation": {
"description": "1-2 sentence explanation of the score",
"type": "string"
},
"score": {
"description": "Relevance score (1-10)",
"maximum": 10,
"minimum": 1,
"type": "integer"
}
},
"required": [
"score",
"explanation"
],
"type": "object"
},
"strict": true
},
"type": "json_schema"
}▶ Token Usage & Performance
{
"completion_tokens": 353,
"predicted_ms": 0,
"prompt_ms": 0,
"prompt_tokens": 443,
"total_tokens": 796
}▶ Context & Parameters (Full JSON)
{
"article_count": 4,
"explanation": "The news story centers on shifting residential and real estate trends in Manhattan following the mayoral election, particularly the unexpected surge in luxury home sales despite predictions of a mass exodus by wealthy residents to Florida or other states. This phenomenon is linked to political outcomes (Mamdani's win), potential tax policy shifts under Governor Hochul, and broader implications for New York City’s real estate market and economic vitality.\n\nWhile not a direct earnings report or Fed decision, this story reflects a significant market trend with real investment implications: the resilience of high-end urban real estate in a time of political uncertainty. The 'Mamdani effect' (or lack thereof) is being cited as a key factor in investor confidence, suggesting that political change did not trigger capital flight — a critical signal for portfolio managers evaluating exposure to urban real estate, especially in major financial centers.\n\nThe surge in luxury home sales in Manhattan indicates sustained demand for premium real estate assets, which can influence real estate investment strategies, capital allocation, and hedging against economic or political volatility. Additionally, the potential for tax hikes under Hochul adds a layer of regulatory risk that investors must consider when assessing long-term returns on property and urban assets.\n\nThis is not routine or minor news — it reflects behavioral shifts in high-net-worth individuals, market sentiment, and macroeconomic trends affecting asset allocation. It provides actionable intelligence for investors in real estate, hedge funds, and institutional portfolios focused on urban centers and macro risk factors.\n\nTherefore, this story is best rated as 8–9: Important analysis with significant implications for investment decisions, market trends, and risk assessment in a key economic region.",
"finish_reason": "stop",
"google_story_id": 24333,
"max_tokens": 2000,
"relevance_score": 8,
"response_format": "json_schema",
"response_format_details": {
"json_schema": {
"description": "Business relevance score for a news story",
"name": "story_relevance",
"schema": {
"additionalProperties": false,
"properties": {
"explanation": {
"description": "1-2 sentence explanation of the score",
"type": "string"
},
"score": {
"description": "Relevance score (1-10)",
"maximum": 10,
"minimum": 1,
"type": "integer"
}
},
"required": [
"score",
"explanation"
],
"type": "object"
},
"strict": true
},
"type": "json_schema"
},
"temperature": 0
}